Skip to main content

Civil Tentative Rulings

Civil Tentative Rulings Announcement

CIVIL TENTATIVE RULING ANNOUNCEMENT

If the Tentative Ruling in your case is satisfactory, you need not appear at the scheduled time, the ruling becomes final, and the prevailing party prepares the order.

However, if you are not satisfied with the Tentative Ruling, and wish to appear and argue the matter, YOU MUST NOTIFY the Clerk’s Office and opposing counsel of your intent before 4:00 p.m. TODAY. If a TELEPHONIC HEARING is requested per CCP §367.5, you MUST register online to appear telephonically using Vcourt.

When doing so, you must indicate as to which issue(s) and/or motion(s) a hearing is being requested. If requesting a hearing for clarification of a tentative ruling, specify what matter(s) and/or issue(s) need clarification.

 You may request a hearing by calling the calendar line at (209) 530-3162 or the main line at (209) 530-3100, prior to 4:00 p.m. - OR- by e-mailing at civil.tentatives@stanct.org Email requests must be made prior to 4:00 p.m. AND confirmed by return e-mail. If you do not receive confirmation e-mail from the clerk, you MUST call (209) 530-3162 to request your hearing.

Please refer to Local Rule of Court 3.12 concerning Court reporter fees.

 If a Hearing is required or you have requested a Hearing for a Law and Motion Matter Scheduled in Department 21, 22, 23 or 24 in Modesto, please contact the Court Reporter Coordinator at (209) 530-3105 or ctreport@stanct.org to request a reporter and determine availability. If a Staff Reporter is not available, you may need to provide your own.

 Effective April 2, 2012

Staff Court Reporters may be available, though it is not guaranteed, to report law and motion matters on the following schedule:

Department 21 - Wednesdays and Fridays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Please call to confirm.

Department 22 - Tuesdays and Thursdays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Wednesdays and Fridays. Please call to confirm.

Department 23 - Wednesdays and Fridays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Please call to confirm.

Department 24 - Tuesdays and Thursdays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Wednesdays or Fridays. Please call to confirm.

If a Staff Reporter is not available, counsel can make arrangements to have their hearing reported by a private CSR. Please contact the Court Reporter Coordinator at (209)530-3105 to request a Staff Reporter and to determine if a Staff Reporter will be available for your hearing

November 19, 2026

                           

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge John R. Mayne in Department 21:

CV-23-005650 - LOPEZ, RAFAEL J vs NGB CONSTRUCTION INC – a) Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Defendant's Compliance with Its Agreed Production of the Documents Described in Plaintiff's Second Amended Notice of Deposition of Defendant's Person(s) Most Knowledgeable; Request for Sanctions - GRANTED, with sanctions in the amount of $2,060; b) Plaintiff's Motion to Continue the Class Certification Briefing Schedule, Settlement Conference, and Trial Date - HEARING REQUIRED.

a) Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure, sections 2025.450 and 2025.480, Plaintiff’s motion to compel is GRANTED. Within 14 days of notice of the signed order, Defendant shall produce all responsive documents and serve a certification regarding the completeness of the production. Defendant shall produce its Person(s) Most Knowledgeable to complete the deposition on a date mutually agreeable by the parties that is between 30-60 days after the production is complete. The Court GRANTS leave to complete only the foregoing discovery proceedings after the initial trial date.

 

The Court issues monetary sanctions in the reduced amount of $1,910.00 against Defendant and its attorney of record, jointly and severally. Defendant and its attorney are to pay the sanctions to Melmed Law Group, P.C., within 20 days of notice of the signed order. The Court will modify and sign the proposed order. Plaintiff to give notice.

 

 

 

Motion to compel

 

On October 13, 2026, Plaintiff filed a motion to compel Defendant’s compliance with Its Agreed Production of the Documents Described in Plaintiff’s Second Amended Notice of Deposition of Defendant’s Person(s) Most Knowledgeable, including a request for sanctions, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure sections 128, 2017.010, 2023.010, 2023.030, 2025.450, 2025.480, and 2031.320, and the Court’s inherent authority. There is no opposition in the Court file.

 

Plaintiff seeks and order (1) compelling Defendant to product all documents responsive to the Requests for Production set forth in Plaintiff’s Second Amended Notice of Deposition of Defendant’s Person(s) Most Knowledgeable, served June 22, 2026; (2) compelling Defendant to product its Person(s) Most Knowledgeable for deposition on a date not less than 30 days after the production is complete, and (3) imposing monetary sanctions in the amount of $3,622.50 for the fees and costs of bringing the instant motion.

 

“If, after service of a deposition notice, a party . . . , without having served a valid objection under Section 2025.410, fails . . . to produce for inspection any document, electronically stored information, or tangible thing described in the deposition notice, the party giving the notice may move for an order compelling the deponent’s attendance and testimony, and the production for inspection of any document, electronically stored information, or tangible thing described in the deposition notice.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 2025.450(a).) “If a deponent fails to answer any question or to produce any document, electronically stored information, or tangible thing under the deponent’s control that is specified in the deposition notice or a deposition subpoena, the party seeking discovery may move the court for an order compelling that answer or production.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 2025.480(a).)

 

Defendant failed to produce documents responsive to numerous requests for production of documents in a deposition notice despite stating that it would produce all responsive documents in its custody, possession, and control. The deposition commenced on July 16, 2026. At the deposition, the parties discussed the failure to produce certain documents. Defendant’s counsel represented that a subset of the requested documents would be produced the next day. Plaintiff suspended the deposition pending completion of the document production. After several email follow-ups and phone calls, Defendant stated that it would provide a supplemental production by September 24, 2026, yet no production was provided.

 

Sanctions

 

Plaintiff seeks sanctions for 5.7 hours of attorney work at a rate of $625.00, plus the $60.00 filing fee, for a total amount of $3,622.50. No opposition was filed. The Court awards 4 hours (including appearance time) at $500 per hour, plus the $60 filing fee, for a total of $2,060.

 

“The court shall impose a monetary sanction under Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 2023.010) against any party, person, or attorney who unsuccessfully makes or opposes a motion to compel an answer or production, unless it finds that the one subject to the sanction acted with substantial justification or that other circumstances make the imposition of the sanction unjust.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 2025.480.)

 

Defendant has not opposed the motion nor otherwise provided any justification for its failure to produce documents responsive to the requests.

 

Motion to Continue

 

On October 15, 2026, Plaintiff field a motion to continue the class certification briefing schedule, settlement conference, and trial date pursuant to California Rules of Court, rules 3.764 and 3.1332, and the Court’s inherent authority to manage its calendar. The Court granted an ex parte application advancing the hearing date to November 19, 2026, and set a briefing schedule. There is no opposition in the Court file.

 

On April 2, 2026 on this 2023 case, the Court sent a kickback to a stipulation to continue trial as follows:

 

Your documents are being returned unsigned. At the time of the setting of the trial, the matter was set

very far out so Plaintiff would have time to file a motion for class certification in time for the trial. This

didn't happen.

 

-

The Court is confused by the choices made and is also confused by the apparent allegation that the

Court wrongfully failed to set a briefing schedule when in fact it is the Court's custom and practice to

either set dates or have the parties seek dates from the clerk's office when they see fit on class action

matters.

 -

The Court hopes to resolve its confusion at a Case Status Review set for April 9, 2026 at 8:30 a.m.

 -

Plaintiff now seeks a continuance because Defendant has failed to produce documents responsive to Plaintiff’s discovery requests, including wage statements and payroll records that are essential to Plaintiff’s case. This may well constitute good cause, but the Court expressed serious concerns over the unnecessary delays and needs a timeline from both parties as to when compliance will be achieved.

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge Stacy P. Speiller in Department 22:

***There are no tentative rulings in Department 22***

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge Clifford Tong in Department 23:

CV-25-005759 - SORIANO, ANGEL MANUEL VS. ASPIRE PUBLIC SCHOOLS – a) Plaintiff Angel Manuel Soriano's Motion to Compel Verified Responses and Production to Demands for Production of Documents, Set One, Against Defendant Modesto City Schools, and Request for Monetary Sanctions – GRANTED, in part, as to sanctions; DENIED, in part, as MOOT; b) Plaintiff Angel Manuel Soriano's Motion to Compel Verified Responses and Production to Demands for Production of Documents, Set One, Against Defendant Aspire Public Schools, and Request for Monetary Sanctions – GRANTED, in part, as to sanctions; DENIED, in part, as MOOT; c) Plaintiff Angel Manuel Soriano's Motion to Compel Verified Responses and Production to Demands for Production of Documents, Set One, Against Defendant Vanguard College Preparatory Academy Community Council, and Request for Monetary Sanctions – GRANTED, in part, as to sanctions; DENIED, in part, as MOOT.

a)   The Court finds that Defendant failed to timely respond to the subject discovery and all objections have been waived. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2031.300(a).) Of note, the “objection only” responses served on 3-16-26 were of no legal effect, as such objections had already been waived due to Defendant’s lack of timely response. However, the Court notes that the request for an order compelling responses appears to be MOOT due to Defendant’s service of verified responses on 10-30-26.

The Court further finds that Plaintiff is entitled to an award of monetary sanctions in connection with this motion, which it appears was necessary in order to elicit Defendant’s service of the subject responses. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2031.300(c), 2023.010, 2030.030 et seq.) Therefore, monetary sanctions in the amount of $300 are awarded against Defendant, payable to Plaintiff’s counsel.

Plaintiff shall serve and submit a revised order consistent with the Court’s ruling herein. (Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.1312.)

b) The Court finds that Defendant failed to timely respond to the subject discovery and all objections have been waived. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2031.300(a).) Of note, the “objection only” responses served on 3-16-26 were of no legal effect, as such objections had already been waived due to Defendant’s lack of timely response. However, the Court notes that the request for an order compelling responses appears to be MOOT due to Defendant’s service of verified responses on 10-30-26.

The Court further finds that Plaintiff is entitled to an award of monetary sanctions in connection with this motion, which it appears was necessary in order to elicit Defendant’s service of the subject responses. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2031.300(c), 2023.010, 2030.030 et seq.) Therefore, monetary sanctions in the amount of $300 are awarded against Defendant, payable to Plaintiff’s counsel.

Plaintiff shall serve and submit a revised order consistent with the Court’s ruling herein. (Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.1312.)

c) The Court finds that Defendant failed to timely respond to the subject discovery and all objections have been waived. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2031.300(a).) Of note, the “objection only” responses served on 3-16-26 were of no legal effect, as such objections had already been waived due to Defendant’s lack of timely response. However, the Court notes that the request for an order compelling responses appears to be MOOT due to Defendant’s service of verified responses on 10-30-26.

The Court further finds that Plaintiff is entitled to an award of monetary sanctions in connection with this motion, which it appears was necessary in order to elicit Defendant’s service of the subject responses. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2031.300(c), 2023.010, 2030.030 et seq.) Therefore, monetary sanctions in the amount of $300 are awarded against Defendant, payable to Plaintiff’s counsel.

Plaintiff shall serve and submit a revised order consistent with the Court’s ruling herein. (Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.1312.)

CV-26-006337 - AVILES, JOSUE vs SMOLINSKIY, YURIY - Defendant Yuriy Smolinkiy's Demurrer to Plaintiff's Complaint – CONTINUED, on the Court’s own motion, to December 18, 2026 at 8:30 a.m. in Department 23.

The moving defendant failed to demonstrate compliance with the provisions of Code Civ. Proc. § 430.41 with regard to meet-and-confer efforts before filing the instant demurrer. Therefore, the hearing is continued for this purpose, and Defendant shall submit a supplemental declaration demonstrating such efforts no later than December 10, 2026.

Defendant is reminded that he is not entitled to special consideration based on his self-represented status and is responsible for following the rules of procedure in the same manner as an attorney practicing before this Court. (ViaView, Inc. v. Retzlaff (2016) 1 Cal.App.5th 198, 208.)

CV-26-008308 - ECONO ROOFING INC vs DURAN, MARIA - Defendants' Demurrer to Complaint – DENIED, as MOOT in view of Plaintiff’s submission of the First Amended Complaint on 11-5-26.

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge David I. Hood in Department 24:

CV-22-005496 - GODINEZ, JESUS vs PLANASA LLC - Final Fairness Hearing – HEARING REQUIRED.

Good cause appearing to the satisfaction of the Court, the Court finds the payment to the Class Representative, to the Class Members and the Class Administrator to be appropriate given all relevant factors of the settlement and in light of the Court’s Preliminary Approval. The Court also finds Class Counsel’s attorney’s fees and costs to be reasonable and comparable to the award of fees generally issued by California Courts.

The Court also notes the effect of the 100% participation rate in this Settlement. The Court is therefore inclined to grant final approval of the Class Action Settlement herein. In accordance with the provisions of Code Civ. Proc. §384, the Court sets a compliance hearing for July 15, 2027, at 8:30 am in Department 24 of this Court to confirm full administration of the settlement.

Class counsel shall submit a compliance report no later than five (5) court days before the date of the hearing, which shall include the total amount that was actually paid to the class members pursuant to the subject settlement. At the time of the compliance hearing, the Court shall amend the judgment to direct that the sum of the unpaid funds, plus interest as required by the statute, be distributed as set forth in the Settlement Agreement. In addition, the Court orders that Notice of the Court’s Order Granting Final Approval and Judgment shall be posted on the Settlement Administrator’s website for a period of at least 90 days. (Civ. Code §1781(g); Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.771(b).

CV-24-007633 - HEITZER, MURRAY vs LIU, ANNA YAN - Plaintiff's Motion for Sanctions Pursuant to CCP 128.7 – DENIED.

As a preliminary matter, the Court again expresses its concern over the spate of sanctions motions by the parties over the past year or so driven largely by the acrimony between Defendant’s and Plaintiff’s former Counsel in what appears to be a bid to settle personal scores compared to the substantive issues in respect of which little to no progress has been made. The Court is hopeful that this is the last sanctions motion to be filed in this matter pursuant to either Code of Civil Procedure sections 128.5 or 128.7 and that the parties will now turn their attention to substantive issues herein.

Plaintiff failed to strictly comply with section 128.7’s safe-harbor requirements. The proposed motion served with Plaintiff’s February 8, 2026, safe-harbor notice sought sanctions under both sections 128.5 and 128.7 and principally asserted that Defendants’ sanctions motion lacked evidentiary support and was brought for an improper purpose. The motion ultimately filed is brought solely under section 128.7 and adds substantive grounds concerning Defendants’ failure to comply with their own safe-harbor obligations and their improper combination of sanctions theories.

Under In re Marriage of Falcone & Fyke (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 814, 827, the papers served during the safe-harbor period must be the same papers ultimately filed with the Court. Although Falcone permitted consideration of the sanctions motion there after additional material was stricken, the trial court ruled solely upon the original motion actually served during the safe-harbor period. CPF Vaseo Associates, LLC v. Gray (2018) 29 Cal.App.5th 997, 1006-1008 likewise requires strict compliance with the statutory safe-harbor procedure and rejects substantial compliance.

Accordingly, the Court does not reach whether Defendants’ underlying sanctions motion was objectively unreasonable or otherwise sanctionable. This disposition is consistent with the Court’s prior ruling denying Defendants’ sanctions motion without prejudice based upon procedural deficiencies without reaching its merits.

Plaintiff’s motion is therefore DENIED. Plaintiff’s request for $3,858.40 in attorney’s fees is therefore also DENIED.

CV-25-009811 - LVNV FUNDING LLC vs VARGAS, MARIA - Plaintiff's Motion for Order that Matters in Request for Admissions be Deemed Admitted Pursuant to CCP 2033.280 – GRANTED, unopposed.

The Court finds that Defendant has failed to timely respond to Plaintiff’s Requests for Admissions, Set One, served on her on January 1, 2026, or at all, without substantial justification.

Plaintiff’s motion is accordingly granted.

Accordingly, all objections to said Requests for Admissions by Defendant are hereby waived. (Code of Civil Procedure §2033.280(a)). Furthermore, said Request for Admissions, Set One, are hereby deemed admitted in this matter for all purposes including trial. (Civ. Proc. Code §§ 2033.250(a), 2033.280 and 2033.410; St. Mary v. Superior Court (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 762).

CV-24-001194 - BELL, WILLIAM vs BENHAM, CHRISTOPHER - Plaintiff's Motion to Lift Stay and Restore Case to the Active Civil Calendar - GRANTED, unopposed.

In light of the Order of the Bankruptcy Court dismissing Defendant Benham’s Benham’s Chapter. 7 bankruptcy proceedings for his failure to appear, the Notice of Entry of the Bankruptcy’s Court’s Order of Dismissal and the termination of Plaintiff’s adversary proceedings therein on July 20, 2026, Plaintiff’s motion is granted.

The stay previously imposed herein due to said bankruptcy proceedings is hereby lifted.

A Case Management Conference is set herein for December 14, 2026, at 8:30 am in Department 24 of this Court.

The following are the tentative rulings for the cases calendared before Commissioner Richard Moths in Department 19 located at the Turlock Division at 300 Starr Avenue, Turlock, CA:

***There are no tentative rulings in Department 19***