Skip to main content

Civil Tentative Rulings

Civil Tentative Rulings Announcement

CIVIL TENTATIVE RULING ANNOUNCEMENT

If the Tentative Ruling in your case is satisfactory, you need not appear at the scheduled time, the ruling becomes final, and the prevailing party prepares the order.

However, if you are not satisfied with the Tentative Ruling, and wish to appear and argue the matter, YOU MUST NOTIFY the Clerk’s Office and opposing counsel of your intent before 4:00 p.m. TODAY. If a TELEPHONIC HEARING is requested per CCP §367.5, you MUST register online to appear telephonically using Vcourt.

When doing so, you must indicate as to which issue(s) and/or motion(s) a hearing is being requested. If requesting a hearing for clarification of a tentative ruling, specify what matter(s) and/or issue(s) need clarification.

 You may request a hearing by calling the calendar line at (209) 530-3162 or the main line at (209) 530-3100, prior to 4:00 p.m. - OR- by e-mailing at civil.tentatives@stanct.org Email requests must be made prior to 4:00 p.m. AND confirmed by return e-mail. If you do not receive confirmation e-mail from the clerk, you MUST call (209) 530-3162 to request your hearing.

Please refer to Local Rule of Court 3.12 concerning Court reporter fees.

 If a Hearing is required or you have requested a Hearing for a Law and Motion Matter Scheduled in Department 21, 22, 23 or 24 in Modesto, please contact the Court Reporter Coordinator at (209) 530-3105 or ctreport@stanct.org to request a reporter and determine availability. If a Staff Reporter is not available, you may need to provide your own.

 Effective April 2, 2012

Staff Court Reporters may be available, though it is not guaranteed, to report law and motion matters on the following schedule:

Department 21 - Wednesdays and Fridays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Please call to confirm.

Department 22 - Tuesdays and Thursdays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Wednesdays and Fridays. Please call to confirm.

Department 23 - Wednesdays and Fridays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Please call to confirm.

Department 24 - Tuesdays and Thursdays only. Staff Reporters may be available on Wednesdays or Fridays. Please call to confirm.

If a Staff Reporter is not available, counsel can make arrangements to have their hearing reported by a private CSR. Please contact the Court Reporter Coordinator at (209)530-3105 to request a Staff Reporter and to determine if a Staff Reporter will be available for your hearing

November 18, 2026

                           

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge John R. Mayne in Department 21:

CV-24-008136 - RODRIGUEZ, MARIBEL ALVAREZ vs COSTCO WHOLESALE CORPORATION - Defendant Costco Wholesale Corporation's Motion for Summary Judgment - HEARING REQUIRED.

 

The Court does not appear to have Plaintiff’s opposition or separate statement.

 

Defendant states that Plaintiff did not provide an electronic copy of Plaintiff’s Statement of Additional Material Facts, and requests additional time to provide a response to Plaintiff’s Additional Material Facts. The Court would like to know if the electronic copy has been provided and intends to continue the hearing.

CV-25-012141 - TORRE, JASMINE MORENO DE LA vs SINGH, JAVRAJ – a) Defendant's Motion to Compel Responses by Plaintiffs to Defendants' Request for Production of Documents, Set One; Request for Sanctions in the Amount of $1,560.00 - GRANTED, with reduced sanctions of $660; b) Defendant's Motion to Compel Responses by Plaintiffs to Defendants' Form Interrogatories, Set One; Request for Sanctions in the Amount of $1,560.00 - GRANTED, with reduced sanctions; c) Defendant's Motion to Compel Responses by Plaintiffs to Defendants' Special Interrogatories, Set One; Request for Sanctions in the Amount of $1,560.00 – GRANTED, with reduced sanctions.

a-c)

Requests for Production

 

Defendants’ unopposed motion to compel responses to Defendants’ Requests for Production of Documents, Set One is GRANTED. The Court GRANTS monetary sanctions in the amount of $660.00 against Plaintiffs and their attorney of record, jointly and severally. The Court will modify and sign the proposed order. Plaintiffs to serve responses no later than 7 days after notice. Plaintiffs and their attorney are to pay the sanctions to Diepenbrock & Cotter, LLP within 7 days of service of the signed order. Defendants to give notice.

 

On September 30, 2026, Defendants filed and served the motion to compel. There is no opposition in the Court file.

 

On January 21, 2026, Defendants propounded Requests for Production, Set One on each Plaintiff. Plaintiffs requested numerous extensions, which Defendant liberally granted. The final extension was to September 14, 2026, yet Plaintiffs served no responses. Defendants subsequently sent a letter noting objections were waived and requesting responses by September 29, 2026, but Plaintiffs served no responses.

 

Counsel requests sanctions for two hours of attorney work at a billing rate of $300.00 per hour. The motion is meritorious, but is uncomplicated.

 

Form Interrogatories

 

Defendants’ unopposed motion to compel responses to Defendants’ Form Interrogatories, Set One is GRANTED. The Court GRANTS monetary sanctions in the amount of $660.00 against Plaintiffs and their attorney of record, jointly and severally. The Court will modify and sign the proposed order. Plaintiffs to serve responses no later than 7 days after notice. Plaintiffs and their attorney are to pay the sanctions to Diepenbrock & Cotter, LLP within 7 days of service of the signed order. Defendants to give notice.

 

On September 30, 2026, Defendants filed and served the motion to compel. There is no opposition in the Court file.

 

On January 21, 2026, Defendants propounded Form interrogatories, Set One on each Plaintiff. Plaintiffs requested numerous extensions, which Defendant liberally granted. The final extension was to September 14, 2026, yet Plaintiffs served no responses. Defendants subsequently sent a letter noting objections were waived and requesting responses by September 29, 2026, but Plaintiffs served no responses.

 

Counsel requests sanctions for two hours of attorney work at a billing rate of $300.00 per hour.

 

Special Interrogatories

 

Defendants’ unopposed motion to compel responses to Defendants’ Special Interrogatories, Set One is GRANTED. The Court GRANTS monetary sanctions in the amount of $660.00 against Plaintiffs and their attorney of record, jointly and severally. The Court will modify and sign the proposed order. Plaintiffs to serve responses no later than 7 days after notice. Plaintiffs and their attorney are to pay the sanctions to Diepenbrock & Cotter, LLP within 7 days of service of the signed order. Defendants to give notice.

 

On September 30, 2026, Defendants filed and served the motion to compel. There is no opposition in the Court file.

 

On January 21, 2026, Defendants propounded Special Interrogatories, Set One on each Plaintiff. Plaintiffs requested numerous extensions, which Defendant liberally granted. The final extension was to September 14, 2026, yet Plaintiffs served no responses. Defendants subsequently sent a letter noting objections were waived and requesting responses by September 29, 2026, but Plaintiffs served no responses.

 

Counsel requests sanctions for two hours of attorney work at a billing rate of $300.00 per hour.

PR-22-001206 - Estate of BRITT, DEBRAH - Petitioner's Amended Motion to Be Relieved as Counsel - GRANTED.

The Court will sign the proposed order.

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge Stacy P. Speiller in Department 22:

***There are no tentative rulings in Department 22***

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge Clifford Tong in Department 23:

CV-25-004183 - TATUM, SUZANNE vs CITY OF TURLOCK - Defendant City of Turlock's Motion for Summary Judgment – CONTINUED to January 7, 2027 at 8:30 a.m. in Department 23 (Code Civ. Proc. § 437c(h)).

The Court has considered Plaintiff’s request for continuance pursuant to Code Civ. Proc. § 437c(h). In light of the law’s preference that matters be fully adjudicated on the merits as well as the particular circumstances presented herein, i.e., that discovery remains open with no trial date presently assigned, the Court GRANTS Plaintiff’s request for a continuance to conduct additional discovery and present supplemental opposition to the Court based thereon. Therefore, the hearing date is CONTINUED, as above.

The parties shall serve and submit supplemental opposition and reply papers within the time periods prescribed by Code Civ. Proc. § 437c

CV-25-005759 - SORIANO, ANGEL MANUEL VS. ASPIRE PUBLIC SCHOOLS – a) Plaintiff Angel Manuel Soriano's Motion to Compel Verified Responses to Special Interrogatories, Set One, Against Defendant Modesto City Schools, and Request for Monetary Sanctions - GRANTED, in part, as to sanctions; DENIED, in part, as MOOT; b) Plaintiff Angel Manuel Soriano's Motion to Compel Verified Responses to Special Interrogatories, Set One, Against Defendant Aspire Public Schools, and Request for Monetary Sanctions – GRANTED, in part, as to sanctions; DENIED, in part, as MOOT; c) Plaintiff Angel Manuel Soriano's Motion to Compel Verified Responses to Special Interrogatories, Set One, Against Defendant Vanguard College Preparatory Academy Community Council, and Request for Monetary Sanctions - GRANTED, in part, as to sanctions; DENIED, in part, as MOOT.

a) The Court finds that Defendant failed to timely respond to the subject discovery and all objections have been waived. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2030.290(a).) Of note, the “objection only” responses served on 3-16-26 were of no legal effect, as such objections had already been waived due to Defendant’s lack of timely response. However, the Court notes that the request for an order compelling responses appears to be MOOT due to Defendant’s service of verified responses on 10-30-26.

The Court further finds that Plaintiff is entitled to an award of monetary sanctions in connection with this motion, which it appears was necessary in order to elicit Defendant’s service of the subject responses. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2030.290(c), 2023.010, 2030.030 et seq.) Therefore, monetary sanctions in the amount of $300 are awarded against Defendant, payable to Plaintiff’s counsel.

Plaintiff shall serve and submit a revised order consistent with the Court’s ruling herein. (Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.1312.)

b) The Court finds that Defendant failed to timely respond to the subject discovery and all objections have been waived. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2030.290(a).) Of note, the “objection only” responses served on 3-16-26 were of no legal effect, as such objections had already been waived due to Defendant’s lack of timely response. However, the Court notes that the request for an order compelling responses appears to be MOOT due to Defendant’s service of verified responses on 10-30-26.

The Court further finds that Plaintiff is entitled to an award of monetary sanctions in connection with this motion, which it appears was necessary in order to elicit Defendant’s service of the subject responses. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2030.290(c), 2023.010, 2030.030 et seq.) Therefore, monetary sanctions in the amount of $300 are awarded against Defendant, payable to Plaintiff’s counsel.

Plaintiff shall serve and submit a revised order consistent with the Court’s ruling herein. (Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.1312.)

c) The Court finds that Defendant failed to timely respond to the subject discovery and all objections have been waived. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2030.290(a).) Of note, the “objection only” responses served on 3-16-26 were of no legal effect, as such objections had already been waived due to Defendant’s lack of timely response. However, the Court notes that the request for an order compelling responses appears to be MOOT due to Defendant’s service of verified responses on 10-30-26.

The Court further finds that Plaintiff is entitled to an award of monetary sanctions in connection with this motion, which it appears was necessary in order to elicit Defendant’s service of the subject responses. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 2030.290(c), 2023.010, 2030.030 et seq.) Therefore, monetary sanctions in the amount of $300 are awarded against Defendant, payable to Plaintiff’s counsel.

Plaintiff shall serve and submit a revised order consistent with the Court’s ruling herein. (Cal. Rules of Ct., rule 3.1312.)

CV-26-005566 - MILLER, LETOMA R vs OLLIVIERRE, LISA LYNN LEWIS - Petitioner Letoma R. Miller's Motion for Award of Attorney's Fees and Costs Against Respondent Lisa Lynn Lewis Ollivierre – GRANTED, in the reduced amount of $2,060.00.

The Court finds that Petitioner has established entitlement to recover reasonable attorney’s fees as the prevailing party herein, based on the Court’s issuance of the requested restraining order. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 527.6(s), 1032(a)(4), 1033.5(a)(10)(B).)

Regarding the lodestar fees calculation, the Court finds that the hourly fee is reasonable based on the relevant factors, including counsel’s skill and experience, the nature of the work performed, the customary billing rate, and the prevailing rate for comparable legal services in the community. (Serrano v Unruh (Serrano IV) (1982) 32 Cal.3d 621, 643; Serrano v Priest (Serrano III) (1977) 20 Cal.3d 25, 48.) In addition, the Court has reviewed the hours claimed by counsel and determines that 4.0 hours were reasonably incurred and substantially contributed to the ultimate successful result herein.(Ketchum v. Moses (2001) 24 Cal.4th 1122, 1132; Horsford v. Board of Trustees of Calif. State University (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 359, 394.) Therefore, the Court finds that the total hours claims shall be reduced by 4.0 hours in that regard.

Therefore, the Court approves the requested fees in the lodestar amount of 4 hours x $450, plus recoverable costs, for a total of $2,060.00 payable to Petitioner’s counsel herein.

The following are the tentative rulings for cases calendared before Judge David I. Hood in Department 24:

CV-25-000345 - CAPITAL ONE NA vs HERNANDEZ, BENNY J - Defendant's Motion to be Relieved as Counsel – GRANTED, unopposed.

Good cause existing Julia Young, Counsel for Defendant’s Motion to be Relieved as Counsel for Defendant is hereby granted.

In order not to work prejudice to Defendant, Counsel’s withdrawal will require a continuance of the pending trial on November 18, 2026.

The Court’s order relieving Counsel shall take effect upon proof of service of same on the client.

CV-25-008770 - THOMAS, RUTH vs STANISLAUS HEALTH & WELLNESS INC - Defendant's Motion to Set Aside Default Judgment as to Defendants Stanislaus Health and Wellness INC. and George Isaac Jacbob – DENIED.

Defendants seek relief under Code of Civil Procedure section 473(b) from the defaults entered on November 14, 2025. The motion was not filed until July 17, 2026, more than six months after entry of default. Section 473(b) requires an application for discretionary relief to be made within a reasonable time, “in no case exceeding six months” after the challenged judgment, order, or proceeding. Where relief is sought from a default, the six-month period runs from entry of default, not entry of a later default judgment. (Manson, Iver & York v. Black (2009) 176 Cal.App.4th 36, 42; Rutan v. Summit Sports, Inc. (1985) 173 Cal.App.3d 965, 970; Kramer v. Traditional Escrow, Inc. (2020) 56 Cal.App.5th 13, 39.) The motion is therefore untimely under section 473(b

Nor have Defendants established that the defaults are void for defective service. As to Stanislaus Health and Wellness Inc., section 415.20(a) permits substituted service, in lieu of personal delivery to a person specified in section 416.10, by leaving the summons and complaint during usual office hours in that person's office with a person apparently in charge and thereafter mailing copies to the person to be served. Formal authorization to accept service is therefore not required of the person apparently in charge. (See Ludka v. Memory Magnetics International (1972) 25 Cal.App.3d 316, 319–321; Khourie, Crew & Jaeger v. Sabek, Inc. (1990) 220 Cal.App.3d 1009, 1012–1013.)

Here, George Isaac Jacob was the corporation’s registered agent for service of process and its CEO and CFO at 1908 Coffee Road, Suite 3. The summons and complaint were left at that office with Claudia Padilla and mailed to George Isaac Jacob at the same address the following day. Although Claudia Padilla declares that she was not authorized to accept service, the record includes George Isaac Jacob’s own communications describing Claudia as the “office manager,” stating that she “runs the office,” and that she is “in charge when I’m not there.” The evidence therefore supports the conclusion that she was a person “apparently in charge” within the meaning of section 415.20(a).

As to George Isaac Jacob individually, the registered process server made three attempts at personal service at his usual place of business on September 19, 23, and 26, 2025 before effecting substituted service on September 29, followed by mailing on September 30. This constitutes reasonable diligence under section 415.20(b). (See Espindola v. Nunez (1988) 199 Cal.App.3d 1389, 1392 [ordinarily two or three attempts at a proper place satisfy reasonable diligence]; Bein v. Brechtel-Jochim Group, Inc. (1992) 6 Cal.App.4th 1387, 1391–1392.)

Accordingly, Defendants have not established a basis to conclude that the defaults are void for lack of service, and their request for discretionary relief under section 473(b) is untimely.

The motion is therefore DENIED.

CV-26-004908 - ESPINOZA, FELIX ANTONIO SIFONTES vs NORCAL CHICKEN INC - Defendant Nor-Cal Chicken, INC’s Motion to Compel Arbitration of Plaintiff's Individual PAGA Claim and to Stay the Non-Individual PAGA Claim - CONTINUED, on the Court’s own motion.

In light of Plaintiff’s upcoming Ex Parte Petition seeking leave to file a late opposition to this motion, this motion is accordingly continued to December 10, 2026, at 8:30 am in Department 24 of this Court.

In the interim, the Court notes service inconsistencies with the Motion to Compel Arbitration. The proofs of service for the English and Spanish Moreno declarations incorrectly identify Case No. CV-26-001740, although the declarations identify this action as Case No. CV-26-004908. The proofs also contain inconsistent service dates and identify service by first-class mail, while the Huie declaration reflects electronic service on September 25, 2026. Defendant shall clarify any inconsistent service method or shall, if applicable, file corrected proofs of service in this action no later than December 3, 2026.

The following are the tentative rulings for the cases calendared before Commissioner Richard Moths in Department 19 located at the Turlock Division at 300 Starr Avenue, Turlock, CA:

***There are no tentative rulings in Department 19***